Child of a Rainless Year by Jane Lindskold
400 pages
Published 2005
Read from June 7 to June 11
Rating: ★★★ out of 5
Jane
Lindskold is one of those authors of middling fame, prominent enough
that I recognize her name from review blurbs on other books, not
ubiquitous enough to be consistently available at your lowest common
denominator chain bookseller. Child of a Rainless Year also
occupies a middling position, halfway between a potentially quite good
supernatural fantasy and one of those tediously detailed "local
interest" books your Aunt Imogene began churning out after she retired
from teaching history at Wapakoneta Junior High. Thrill as the narrator
digs her teeth into this dialogue: "I read about the Plaza Hotel in some
of the books you loaned me. Weren't the tin-work ceilings covered for a
long time, and only recently restored?" Chill as our heroine pores
through genealogical records and grills chicken dishes for visiting
estate lawyers!
Much (way, way too much) of the book's length is
given over to "I woke up, I got dressed in this sassy but sensible
outfit with perfect accessories, and then I made a delicious breakfast
and went out to learn more about local history" narration. Which is a
shame, because despite all that, I think the story itself had promise. I
like a good slow burn from time to time, and there were just enough
hints of weirdness and memorable characterization and creepy description
in the early going to keep me happy. By the middle of the book, though,
just as the weird elements were ever so slowly coming to the
foreground, I found my interest waning. "Magical realism/urban fantasy
set in New Mexico" is right up my alley -- in fact, that's the sole
reason I picked up this book -- but I can only grind my way through so
much middle class verisimilitude in my fiction. There's a reason I don't
pick up more literary fiction about rich white people getting married
and moving to Napa Valley to be unhappy together, or rich white kids
getting strung out on expensive drugs and having miserable parties with
the young urban beautiful, or whatever -- the shit's boring. This may be
the first fantasy novel I've ever read that focused more on estate
lawyering and home restoration than on anything, well, fantastical. It
was less House of Leaves, more afternoon HGTV marathons. I like
the occasional low-key fantasy, but the second half of this story was so
low-key it was almost muted.
I'm tempted to return the other
Lindskold book in my library box unread, but "plucky young heroine vs.
treacherous noblewoman in a race to uncover a lost pyramid" sounds too
delightful to pass up. Besides, I like Lindskold's prose, and before I
give up on her entirely, I'd like to see her apply it to something that
isn't so utterly squaresville.
No comments:
Post a Comment